• Skip to main content

Simon Collister, PhD

Strategy + Consulting

  • About Simon
  • News
  • Contact

Web 2.0

Steve Rubel says search is broken…

10/16/2007 by simoncollister Leave a Comment

Very little time to post at the moment but a quick note about a good post from Steve Rubel who recently opined that search is broken… and I would have to agree with him.

In a nutshell, search, as we know it, trawls traditional (web 1.0) content very efficiently – as it always has. But now the sheer volume and complexity of user-generated content across – and within – a range of different platforms is challenging the effectiveness of traditional search algorithms.

As Steve says:

"We need a secure, opt-in web version of Google Desktop that can find
all the bits we generate online, even if they are behind walls."

The interesting thing here is that while we evangelise the fundamental changes technology is bringing to the way we do business and organise our companies; knowledge and information, we often overlook some of the key tools we use everyday.

Search is pretty much the cornerstone of our daily web-activity… but like everything else is being out-paced by the sheer speed of technological development.

Technorati tags: Search, Steve Rubel, Web 2.0, Technology

Filed Under: search, Web 2.0

More CampaignTV

10/09/2007 by simoncollister Leave a Comment

There was an article in yesterday’s Media Guardian which gives more of an insight into Campaign TV [paywalled] – the left-leaning online video site which I blogged about at the weekend.

Gez Sagar, one of the founders, tells Meg Carter:

"The Labour Party and trades unions make many films … some of these have recently been made available to a wider audience via YouTube but the quality isn’t great and you can’t guarantee what other pieces of content you might end up next to."

Uh-oh. Two things spring to mind which Gez might want to consider:

  1. ‘what demand is there for high-quality campaign videos?’ – Webcameron and 18 Doughty Street by Gez’s own admission are the most successful british politics video sites and do they offer ‘high-quality’, party endorsing video content? Erm. No, they’re successful because they contain genuine, engaging and interesting content.
     
  2. ‘you can’t guarantee what other pieces of content you might end up next to’ – And that is a problem because…. essentially YouTube’s ability to distribute its content is a major benefit to anyone wishing to empower its audience rather than a drawback. By giving people the ability to use and personalise your content you’re allowing them to evangelise and advocate the cause on your behalf.

Still it’s early days and Gez, you know where you can get hold of me.

Technorati tags: Media Guardian, CampaignTV, Gez Sagar

Filed Under: Current Affairs, edemocracy, Politics, social media, Web 2.0

Set organisational bloggers free….

10/02/2007 by simoncollister Leave a Comment

Network

Fantastic post from Jeff Jarvis demonstrating that while more and more
organisations are understanding the intrinsic benefits of blogging they aren’t
understanding the instrumental benefits. 

Jarvis applies his argument to newspapers – an ideal industry to
generate significant numbers of corporate bloggers – and suggests that while
newspapers are rapidly adopting blogging as a communication channel they are
burying their bloggers deep inside the website hidden under layers of ’proper’
content and unmemorable URLs.

The solution, says Jarvis, is to serve up newspaper bloggers as
individual units of blog content and connect them to the newspaper’s main site
as part of it network. So, to use Jarvis’s idea floated earlier this year: have
the newspaper homepage as a hub for loads of really useful, interesting and
timely networked content. 

As Jarvis puts it:

“Architecturally, this returns to the idea that news
sites shouldn’t be sites at all but larger, looser networks
and not just of
stuff they make but also — who can afford to make it all — stuff others make.
It also points to the problem of presuming that sites can and should still
consider themselves destinations; this, I argued,
is one of the lessons of the death of Timesselect.”

By doing this the newspapers can reap the rewards:

  • lots of blogs at lots of
    addresses means lots of people creating lots of brands – all for the newspaper
  • An element of separation
    between blogger and newspaper makes it easier to write content with a human
    voice, not “the cold voice of the institution”
  • The only way for these
    bloggers to spread and grow is to join in and link to other conversations 

In Jarvis’s own words:

“We are seeing the links and
the voice. But the architecture remains a problem … The blogs may be getting
more plentiful and they are getting better. But now they’re ready to move out
of the house and find homes of their own.
”

Now apply this thinking to
corporate or organizational blogs. All too often the in-house marketing manager or PR agency wants a blog to tell the firm’s story to the world. They will hopefully
understand the intrinsic principles, but what about the instrumental – or
‘architectural’ – principles?

Technorati tags: Jeff Jarvis, Newspapers, corporate+blogging, networks

Filed Under: blogs/blogging, Jeff Jarvis, Newspapers, Web 2.0

Miliband’s blog is back… this time with some friends

09/28/2007 by simoncollister Leave a Comment

Work is manic as per and as a resutl I haven’t logged into my personal bloglines account in days.

However, I have just come across the news that Foreign Secretary, David Miliband is back blogging – which is great news.

Fco_home

Even better news is the fact that the site is caleld ‘FCO Bloggers’ which to me indicates that there is more than one FCO blog. So I has me a little look around…. and lo and behold there’s a link to ‘All FCO blogs‘.

Fco_bloggers

Nice one, Dave! The page declares:

"This blog space provides a place for Ministers and officials to engage
in a dialogue with you about international affairs and the work of the
Foreign and Commonwealth Office. We want these personal blogs to be a
genuine sharing of ideas, so we will try to read the comments you post
here and respond to the debate."

So it’s all starting to look like a really good effort to help open up the FCO to a wider world.

In case you can’t read the profiles, the FCO bloggers are:

  • David Miliband, Foreign Secretary
  • Lindsay Appleby, First Secretary, Brussels
  • Sarah Russell, new entrant
  • Jim Murphy, Minister for Europe
  • Maria Pia Gazzella, Trade Officer, Santiago
  • Sir Sherard Cowper-Coles, Ambassador to Afghanistan

Hopefully we’ll get some really good material from across the FCO’s global remit. There’s also an FCO YouTube channel and Flickr stream

Technorati tags: FCO, Foreign and Commonwealth Office, David Miliband, blogging, government

Filed Under: blogs/blogging, David Miliband, edemocracy, social media, Web 2.0

*UPDATED* Twitter is about people, not technology… how many times?

09/24/2007 by simoncollister 2 Comments

Twitter_full_2

*UPDATED*Further to my previous thoughts on online identity, Doc SearlsDave Winer has a nifty little post about how we engage with social networks (including Twitter) differently.

"When people get together to discuss Twitter, and perhaps other social
networks (and Twitter is that, a bare-bones social network), they often
discuss as if there were a common user experience, but this is a
misperception, there are many different experiences …

On Twitter I try to keep a ten percent ratio of people I follow over
people who follow me. For other people, maybe most, the ratio is
1-to-1, they follow approximately the same number of people as follow
them. Scoble follows
thousands
of people. For him Twitter is like a very fast chatroom. For me it’s
like weblogs.com on a busy day in 2002. I’ve seen people who follow 0
people, for them Twitter is a publishing environment. Very different
experiences. To each of them Twitter is a different product."

Very astute point (obviously)… and something PR and marketing people should take into account when thinking about measurement.

We are dealing with social tools being put to social uses. It’s not simply a case of measuring Twitter as Twitter. It’s about measuring Twitter as totally diverse group of Twitterers each using the tool for different purposes

That’s the difficulty (impossiblility?). And the usual metrics suspects probably aren’t the right people to be doing the measuring.

Technorati tags: social networks, Twitter, Dave Winer, measurement, metrics

Filed Under: Dave Winer, Online identity, social networking, Twitter, Web 2.0

Measurement and Metrics once more

09/23/2007 by simoncollister Leave a Comment

Just a short note on the debate around measurement and metrics on the web. James Cherkoff has a good round up of the issues involved which can be summed neatly as follows:

"a recent McKinsey report shows that despite the fact that the web can offer data like no other, it still hasn’t come up with a metrics package and system that is sufficently user-friendly and stable to attract the really big brand budgets … A top media executive
described the same idea to me very succinctly as: "We know the bike is broken, but it’s the only one we’ve got".

I think most us would agree with that, but we really need to start looking at ways to measure the web in line with the new ways it changes the way we interact. We won’t be able to get anywhere near a half-decent metric as long as we’re still forcing traditional adSmallervertising/marketing/PR measurement frameworks over a revolutionised and revolutionising medium.

In other news the Society for New Communications Research has announced the start of a research project "titled New Media, New Influencers and Implications
for the PR Profession
, will explore the impact of Web 2.0 and social
media tools on communications and the public relations profession."

It’ll be interesting to see if there’s a chapter dealing with the elusive measurement issue.

Technorati tags: James Cherkoff, measurement, metrics, Society for New Communications Research, Web 2.0

Filed Under: New media, Research, social media, Web 2.0

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 8
  • Page 9
  • Page 10
  • Page 11
  • Page 12
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 19
  • Go to Next Page »

Copyright © 2026